No strings attached
It's likely that in sharing this post, I'll alienate a few people. It's also likely that I'll fail to adequately convey my point. I may very well be misunderstood. Nonetheless, this is something I've thought about time and again and I think it's worth broaching and discussing.
In a nutshell, I've come to the conclusion that blogging can fall victim to an excess of politesse and reciprocity.
I read blogs because they introduce me to new people, places, and ways of looking at things. I read blogs written by people I'm fairly certain I'd adore in real life. I also read blogs written by people I would undoubtedly not get along with. I read blogs because they amuse, educate, pique, entertain, challenge, soothe, inform, or inspire me in some way. I don't read blogs solely because the author reads my blog. There are blogs I read regularly with no reciprocation whatsoever. Conversely, I'm certain there are people who read my blog without reciprocity from me.
I write a blog for a variety of reasons. I write for the sweet challenge of the written word. For the joy of self-expression. For the catharsis of sharing challenges or triumphs. For the connection and camaraderie.
Since at least part of writing a blog involves the pleasure of reaching or connecting with others, I genuinely appreciate comments. A comment is proof that my words have not simply echoed endlessly into the void. (Someone actually read what I wrote!) However, I'm bothered by the idea of tit-for-tat commenting. If I write a post that you can connect with in some way, great. Maybe you relate to what I've said. Or you think I'm off my rocker. Or it makes you laugh. So far so good. But if you leave a comment because you feel that you owe me one, or because it seems like you should, that's not so good. I hate the idea that a person would ever feel an obligation to comment. If visits and comments are nothing more than rote reciprocations, I think they lose some of their value.
At times, I receive a comment from an individual I've not heard from before. It makes sense to pay a visit and see if there's something of interest to me at their blog. Realistically, there's a possibility nothing will grab me and that will be the end of it. I'm not being mean, just honest. It simply isn't possible for me to forge a connection with every person who reads my blog and vice versa.
Sometimes when an online friend leaves a comment on one of my posts, it reminds me to check in on them. And when I arrive at their blog, I may find something I want to reply to. But I may just read a few things without commenting. I read oodles of posts that I don't comment on. If I don't leave a comment, it doesn't mean I didn't enjoy the post. If I took the time to compose a meaningful response for every item I read, I would have to give up blogging: it would consume far more time than I have to spare. It's a shame that comments are nearly the only indicator we have that an item's been read.
If I frequent your blog, it's because I enjoy it. I visit when time allows. I read what interests me. I may or may not comment, so you won't always be aware of my presence. If you read my blog and you suspect I don't regularly read yours, don't take it personal. There are only so many hours in the day.
I think we might all be more content if the acts of writing and reading blogs were less closely entwined.
My attitude toward blogging is probably influenced by my age and my introvert personality. I suspect my age group is less accustomed to the interactive, give-and-take nature of the online world. My formative years were a more passive age, e.g. television and radio did not invite or expect a response. Whatever the reason, sometimes I just want to absorb without the need to respond.
For me, blogging is a source of enjoyment. I refuse to let it become a job, with a list of visits to be made, and a quota of comments to be left. That would zap all the fun out of it.
I'd love to hear from you if you have any thoughts you'd like to share on this issue. But, please, only if you feel like it. :)
Comments
LOL...you shared all the same thoughts I have on this subject...so there is really nothing left for me to say. I think a lot of people feel this way.
I wish I could comment more on posts I enjoy, but I don't have the time. I have about a gajillion neighbors and most of the posts "amuse, educate, pique, entertain, challenge, soothe, inform, or inspire me in some way," and are therefore very "commentable." But because of time limitations, I have to pick and choose when I comment.
But I do agree. I don't think reciprocal commenting is how blogging should work. It's not a tit-for-tat issue. I comment when I feel like I have something to say. Not just to be nice or so that someone will comment on my blog. That's just ridiculous, IMHO.
How would anyone be alienated? All you've done is express succinctly and wonderfully the correct reasons for reading - not surfing - other people's blogs.
'The sweet challenge of the written word' - fabulous and exact phrase! It's the reason to write and to read: to read how others have met their own particular challenges.
However, I'm also very strict about my levels of filtering and will never put someone in my 'hood just because they did me. I also dump people out of my 'hood when I lose interest in what they're talking about. It's not personal, it's just, like Cori wrote above, often time related. What they have to say isn't engaging to me.
But the interesting dialog is that we're putting things out there, sometimes very personal things, without really *knowing* who is reading. You've locked it? Well, there's copy and paste and someone could forward your words on. We've become a world of voyeurs into people's lives, with the hope that they're getting something out of it, whether they comment on it or not.
That said, my inclinations are to comment when I feel moved to, for whatever reason. I read most everyone in my neighborhood's posts, but often don't leave a comment. Part of it is time, part of it is that I don't have anything in particular to add to the conversation.
This whole online world is an interesting social experiment and I love reading people's thoughts on it and approaches to it. Thanks for sharing yours.
I think what you had to say was spot on. I love comments but that's not why I blog and I love making comments and having a "dialoge" of sorts with others posts but certainly don't feel the need to comment on everything there's only so much time to devote to this area of my life after all! At times I feel like blogging can get a little catty, like high school. I mostly just ignore that though, I don't have time for it.
I think you have written everything I think about in terms of blogging/commenting. I don't often come on vox so much nowadays and skim over posts, and read some when I do find the time, I don't like feeling like I *have* to comment on peoples blogs all the time. I have been known in the past to get messages from people asking if I read their latest post, and "ooh but you haven't commented yet". That really infuriates me actually!!
Hmm, the black hole analogies are adding up in your commnets. Interesting.
I thought your post was very worthwhile reading. The commnetss you made (above) especially resonated with me--we are roughly the same age--from a time when one did not interact with household electronics in any way like we do now, save for the telephone perhaps.
I'm in an odd postion of actually doing paid blogging so I blog all the time. Vox is almost always coming last now as evidenced by the fact that I'm very late to comment here. I used to stress about missing neighbours. Now I just do my best, sometimes leaving a very short comment which is my way of saying "Hello, I thought of you."
Wanted to add as well that there's nothing remotely off-putting here. Anyone that would take offence is taking your comments about your feelings in re: blogging too personally.You are entitled to not worry about such thngs.
Cheers!
I almost never comment on blogs and I almost never respond to a comment left on my blog. I've often thought of doing a post very much like this one because I have wanted to ensure those that I do keep up with that I am actually still here, reading away. Just because I don't comment doesn't mean I'm not entertained or affected. It often just means that I don't have anything to add to the already brilliant points or funny antics made in the actual blog post.
I know exactly what you mean when you talk about people commenting out of obligation. I'd rather get no comment at all than comments that are flat.
When I first starting blogging, it was for the audience I had or hoped to gain. Now, it's for me. I kind of feel like that unless blogging is a job I'm being paid for I shouldn't worry about who is reading and how they're responding.
Excellent post, my dear.
Thanks for expressing what many have been thinking about the blogging relationship~
i don my cap